1 week ago
Can a sitting President dismiss or delay his cases, or even pardon himself? Trump's legal battles in both federal and state courts add a new dimension to his presidency, setting up a term unlike any in U.S. history. This article explores each case and its potential impact on his administration.
US captain Donald Trump, full of enthusiasm after victory, takes the stage with wife Melania to deliver victory speech in West Palm Beach, Florida
UPDATED: Nov 11, 2024 21:43 IST
Donald Trump is set to re-enter the White House as the 47th President of the United States, marking an extraordinary moment in American history. This is the first time a U.S. President has faced multiple criminal charges while preparing to take office. With cases spanning federal and state courts, Trump’s return has raised questions about what will happen to his four ongoing legal battles. Could he end these cases, or will they linger throughout his presidency?
An Unprecedented Situation
Trump’s victory is a historic milestone, not only for his political comeback but for the legal questions it poses. Trump’s criminal charges, which include a New York hush-money case, a federal case related to January 6, a classified documents case, and a Georgia election case, put the country in legally uncharted territory. While a sitting U.S. President cannot be prosecuted in federal cases, the outcome of these state cases remains uncertain.
Federal Cases: Will They Be Dropped?
As President-elect, Trump may soon gain the power to influence the two federal cases against him: the January 6 insurrection case and the classified documents case. Special Counsel Jack Smith charged Trump with attempting to overturn the 2020 election and mishandling classified documents. The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled Trump has partial immunity from criminal prosecution for actions undertaken while in office, but Smith has refiled the cases, arguing that his actions went beyond official duties. However, Trump’s lawyers are now discussing whether his status as President-elect could end these prosecutions.
Neama Rahmani, a former federal prosecutor, claims, “It’s well established that a sitting President can’t be prosecuted,” implying that the January 6 case may be dismissed. Trump himself has hinted that he would “fire” Smith if elected, creating the possibility that both federal cases could be dropped, especially if the Department of Justice cites its 2000 policy that prosecuting a President would disrupt executive functions.
The New York Hush-Money Case: Delays Expected
Trump’s legal battles at the state level are more complicated. The New York hush-money case involves charges of falsifying business records related to payments to an adult film star, a conviction that made Trump the first former President to be found guilty of such an offence. His sentencing, originally scheduled for September, was delayed to 26 November — after the election. Former prosecutor Julie Rendelman notes that, as a first-time offender and given his age, Trump is unlikely to be sentenced to prison time, though appeals may continue for years. Trump’s legal team is expected to argue that sentencing would impede his duties, and the judge could be persuaded to delay proceedings until Trump leaves office.
The Georgia Election Case: A Tougher Battle
The Georgia case may be Trump’s most challenging. Here, Trump faces charges for his alleged attempts to overturn his 2020 defeat in the state. Efforts to remove District Attorney Fani Willis, who is leading the case, are ongoing, but if these fail, the case is expected to be paused during his presidency. Trump’s legal team argues that trying him as a sitting President would violate the “supremacy clause” of the U.S. Constitution, effectively shielding him from trial until he leaves office.
According to Trump’s lawyer, Steve Sadow, Trump’s presidential duties mean that this trial should not proceed while he holds office. Legal scholars suggest that while state prosecutors can delay proceedings, they may eventually face obstacles that prevent them from taking a sitting President to trial.
Can a President Pardon Himself?
One pressing question is whether Trump could pardon himself. Article II of the U.S. Constitution grants the President the authority to issue pardons for federal offenses, which could theoretically allow Trump to end the federal cases against him. This power does not extend to state cases, however, which means that the New York and Georgia cases would remain outside his control. Legal scholars are divided on whether a self-pardon is constitutional, as no U.S. President has tried to pardon themselves before, but many believe a legal challenge would arise if Trump attempted it.
What Lies Ahead for Trump’s Legal Woes?
As Trump prepares to take office, his legal issues add layers of uncertainty to his presidency. Federal cases may be dismissed or delayed, allowing him to serve without immediate repercussions. In contrast, the state cases will likely face delays, but their eventual outcomes remain unknown. Trump’s ascension has prompted intense debates over presidential immunity and self-pardoning, issues the U.S. judicial system has never addressed.
For now, Trump’s presidency stands as a symbol of both resilience and division in American politics. The cases against him will continue to spark debate about the boundaries of presidential power and accountability, creating a complex and potentially transformative chapter in U.S. legal and political history.
Published By:
indiatodayglobal
Published On:
Nov 11, 2024
