Shares of Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Ltd. fell as much as 5.5% in reaction to their September quarter results on Monday, November 16. The numbers were reported after market closing hours on Friday, which showed another quarter of losses for the company, due to multiple one-offs.
Brokerage firm Motilal Oswal has maintained its "sell" rating on Tata Motors PV after its results, and has also cut its earnings estimates for the stock, along with its price target, which has been lowered to ₹240, implying a downside potential of 16% from Friday's closing levels.
Shares of Tata Motors PV have already corrected 22% so far this year.
Motilal Oswal has slashed its Earnings Per Share (EPS) estimates for Tata Motors PV by 69% for financial year 2027 and by 5% for financial year 2028, citing the multiple headwinds to Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) due to continued pressure from VME costs, commodity prices, persistent softness in Chinese demand, higher interest costs as a result of increased debt, and a downward revision to its full year margin guidance. This, coupled with a raw material inflation impact to the India business, is likely to keep these margins under pressure as well, the brokerage wrote in its note.
While JLR has embarked on a major cost-cutting initiative, it is likely to only help partially offset the current headwinds. Given the significant challenges at JLR and continued geopolitical uncertainty, we reiterate our "SELL" rating on the stock.
MOTILAL OSWAL ON TATA MOTORS PV
Motilal Oswal values JLR and the India PV business at 2 times and 13 times Enterprise Value to EBITDA respectively.
Citi Says Sell Tata Motors PV
Citi has maintained its "sell" rating on Tata Motors PV, with a price target of ₹235. It said that the results were below expectations for both India and the JLR business, though the margin miss was sharper for JLR.
For JLR, there are severe headwinds to demand and profitability, according to Citi, who added that the PV volumes remain strong for the India business, driven by a robust product pipeline, even as margins remain a concern.
Citi highlighted the revenue, EBIT and Free Cash Flow guidance cut behind its sell call.
Nomura Stays On The Sidelines
Nomura has maintained its "neutral" rating on the stock, with a price target of ₹287, which is the same price at which the stock closed on Friday.
It said that although the PV outlook for the India business is strong, margin risks persist. It expects five new vehicle launches over the next 18 months, which will support the company's revenue growth going forward.
How Did Tata Motors PV Fare In Q2?
For the September quarter, Tata Motors PV reported a 34% growth in its overall topline to ₹96,920 crore, but that figure turned out to be lower than the CNBC-TV18 poll estimate of ₹1 lakh crore.
The company also reported a net loss of ₹5,531 crore, compared to a net profit of ₹76,170 crore during the same quarter last year. The net loss was due to exceptional items worth ₹6,738 crore during the quarter.
Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation and Amortisation (EBITDA) for the quarter stood at ₹4,866 crore, compared to an EBITDA loss of ₹1,404 crore.
JLR's revenue guidance has been lowered to £25 billion from £26 billion earlier, while the EBIT margin guidance was cut to 2% to 3% from 4% earlier. The free cash flow is also likely to be a negative £1.25 billion from the earlier breakeven projecton.
Shares of Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles are trading 5.3% lower in early trading on Monday at ₹272.1.
Tata Motors PV shares fall over 5% after multiple price target cuts on Q2 loss, JLR guidance revision

11 minutes ago
