What Trump 2.0 could mean for Indian Americans

As Donald Trump prepares to return to the White House, the 4.5 million-strong Indian-American community in the US finds itself at a pivotal crossroads. With a reputation for contributing significantly to the economy, technology, medicine, and education, Indian Americans are both keen observers and active participants in the political shifts that could shape their future. Trump’s first term brought a mix of opportunities and challenges, and a potential second term promises to further redefine the landscape for this influential group.

Here’s an exploration of what a Trump 2.0 presidency might mean for Indian-Americans, addressing critical areas of immigration, entrepreneurship, community dynamics, US-India relations, and shifting political allegiances within the diaspora.

Trump’s first term was marked by deepening US-India relations, driven in part by his rapport with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. High-profile events like the 2019 'Howdy Modi' rally in Houston and the 2020 'Namaste Trump' event in Ahmedabad showcased a mutual commitment to stronger ties. This alignment was further solidified by shared strategic goals, particularly in countering China's growing influence in Asia through platforms like the Quad alliance.

For Indian-Americans, these strengthened ties bolstered their identity as a cultural and economic bridge between the two nations. Businesses within the diaspora benefited from increased collaboration in technology and trade, while cultural exchanges fostered a deeper understanding between the two countries.

CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR TRADERS

While Trump’s earlier tenure strengthened strategic ties, trade disputes occasionally created friction. Issues over tariffs on steel, aluminium, and agricultural products led to strained negotiations. However, a Trump 2.0 administration could provide a fresh opportunity for recalibration.

Indian-American business leaders, particularly those engaged in bilateral trade, have an opportunity to advocate for and shape policies that benefit both nations. For example, companies in sectors like pharmaceuticals, textiles, and technology could champion tariff reductions or streamlined regulatory frameworks, paving the way for smoother trade relations. Additionally, diaspora-led initiatives could help align US priorities with both, 'Make in America' and India’s 'Make in India' campaigns, fostering mutual economic growth.

OPPORTUNITIES AND RISKS FOR ENTREPRENEURS

Indian-American entrepreneurs contribute significantly to the economy through businesses ranging from retail to tech startups. Trump’s first term delivered mixed results for this community. While his administration’s tax cuts and deregulation policies boosted businesses, uncertainties around trade and tariffs presented new challenges.

A Trump 2.0 presidency may again emphasise deregulation and tax incentives, creating growth opportunities, particularly for small businesses. However, the resurgence of 'America First' policies could pose challenges for Indian-American entrepreneurs with global supply chains or business ties to India.

For those navigating industries like technology, manufacturing, and retail, maintaining profitability amid potential trade disruptions will require strategic planning. The question for Indian-American business owners is not just how to adapt but how to leverage Trump-era policies to build resilience and expand opportunities.

EMERGING SHIFTS IN DIASPORA POLITICS

Historically, Indian-Americans have overwhelmingly supported the Democratic Party, drawn by its progressive stance on immigration, diversity, and social justice. However, Trump’s presidency marked a notable shift, with a big section of the community leaning toward the Republican Party.

Economic policies favouring tax cuts and deregulation, coupled with a shared emphasis on traditional values like family and education, have attracted affluent and conservative Indian Americans to the Republican fold. Prominent figures like Nikki Haley and Vivek Ramaswamy have further amplified the community’s visibility within the GOP.

Frustrations with the Democratic Party’s perceived inaction on immigration reforms, including the Green Card backlog, have also fueled this shift. As Indian-Americans reassess their political affiliations, Trump’s policies could accelerate this trend, redefining the diaspora’s role in American politics.

COMMUNITY DYNAMICS IN A POLARISED US

Trump’s presidency saw a rise in xenophobia and hate crimes, including incidents targeting South Asians. For Indian Americans, its impact cannot be ignored. Many in the community felt marginalised by the broader cultural environment under the 'Make America Great Again' banner, even as Trump courted their support through high-profile events like the 'Howdy Modi' rally in Houston.

A second Trump term could amplify these tensions. Advocacy groups and community organisations will likely play an even more significant role in safeguarding the rights and dignity of Indian Americans, pushing back against discriminatory rhetoric and policies.

However, it’s essential to recognise the nuanced relationship between Indian-Americans and Trump’s leadership. His alignment with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and support for a stronger US-India partnership have resonated with the diaspora. These shared values — emphasising nationalism, family, and economic independence — highlight the duality of Indian-American sentiment toward Trump.

IMMIGRATION POLICIES

For decades, the H1-B visa programme has been a cornerstone of Indian professionals’ success in America, particularly in fields like technology and healthcare. During Trump’s first term, this vital pipeline faced significant disruptions. Stricter eligibility criteria, heightened scrutiny, and an unpredictable approval process created widespread uncertainty among Indian workers and their families.

Under a second Trump administration, these challenges could intensify. Indian workers already stuck in a decades-long Green Card backlog may face additional hurdles. Families relying on H-4 visa work permits, often used by spouses, remain vulnerable, as Trump previously sought to revoke their work authorisation. Such changes could disproportionately impact Indian women, many of whom use these permits to contribute to household incomes and professional growth.

The ripple effect extends to US businesses that rely heavily on skilled Indian talent to drive innovation. Further restrictions on work visas could exacerbate labour shortages in key sectors, affecting the broader economy. For Indian Americans, the stakes are high: their ability to integrate and thrive in the US hinges on reforms to an increasingly complex immigration system.

LOOKING AHEAD

The potential return of Donald Trump to the White House presents a mix of opportunities and challenges for Indian Americans. Immigration policies, entrepreneurial prospects, community dynamics, US-India relations, and shifting political loyalties will all play a part in shaping the diaspora’s future.

Navigating these complexities requires resilience, advocacy, and adaptability. Indian Americans must remain engaged in the political process, leveraging their growing influence to push for reforms and policies that reflect their interests. Organisations representing the diaspora will play a critical role in ensuring their voices are heard, their rights protected, and their contributions recognised.

Ultimately, Trump 2.0 is not just about what the former president might do, it’s about how Indian-Americans respond. Their ability to unite, strategise, and advocate for their community will determine whether they emerge stronger in the face of uncertainty. For a group that has long exemplified the American dream, this next chapter could be one of reinvention, empowerment, and progress.

(Rohit Sharma is an award-winning journalist residing in Washington DC)
(Views expressed in this article are those of the author)

Tune In